In praise of hippies
Why yes, I did see What the Bleep do we Know a couple weeks back, and it did irritate me that many of those interviewed employed logical fallacies that I can recognize but not name, and I did think it long-jumped to conclusions, and I almost did want to point the two women in the hippie shop today to the Randi skewering of the Emoto “Talking to Water” pictures they were so reverently discussing about sharing with their clients.
But part of me is kind of disappointed that nobody has bothered, you know, just for kicks, to do a real double-blind version of “Talking to Water.” Because, you know, part of me really hopes there’s something to it. But even within the context of the movie in which I first saw the “experiment”, there’s several alternate routes explained for the body/mind connection–some of which, you know, are actually physiologically based and stuff. “Talking to Water” is a pretty story, but I think we can skim off the moral without swallowing the entire glass, ladies.
And it’s not that double-blind is THE standard to which I think everything should be held–I love placebos. The efficacy of placebos is, what, 25%? 30? That’s why drugs have to be better than them. I recognize the healing value that placebos can possess, but I wish that people didn’t need to pay $20 to Boiron so they can get their placebo effect.
Anyway. The hippie store. My doc wrote me an anti-anxiety script this morning to tide me over until my life has settled down a little, and while I appreciate the gesture and am getting it filled in case I work myself into a panic attack, I don’t really want to take it. So I went to the hippie store to look for some placebos.
During my interview at the pharmacy school I’m now waiting to hear from, I was asked about why patients come to the compounding pharmacy at which I work. I answered, of course, that we do a lot of stuff other pharmacies can’t: custom flavoured suspensions or emulsions; accomodating allergies; veterinary dosing; tweaking levels–but mostly bioidentical hormones. One of my interviewers pointed out that there’s a lot of debate over bioidentical hormones, and while I can’t speak directly to the efficacy of our bioidentical formulations, I can tell you that customers keep coming back, and that they tell their friends. I pack at least 4000 capsules of progesterone each month.
Whether bioidentical hormones offer superior benefits is debatable. Whether the patients in our care are happier that they are in our care, I feel, isn’t. It may just be that the pharmacists at our store listen. And that’s what the lady at the hippie store did for me. She also touched my feet and chanted a bit, but afterwards, I felt better. And I don’t really fucking care whether she just waved her hands and mumbled or if she was helping my heart chakra or whatever. I’ll take my placebo and run.